INTRODUCTION
Chat systems is one of the
computer-mediated communication (CMC) systems which is a multi-user
synchronous communication facility that is available all over the world
to people with access to the Internet network of computer systems. They
are intended to be a tool for social interaction between spatially
dispersed people using the medium of computers.
Interaction on
chat systems involves a deconstruction of traditional assumptions about
the dynamics of communication, and the construction of alternative
systems called “Internet language” (Reid, 1991).
CONVERSATIONAL ANALYSIS
Conversational Analysis
which was advanced by Sacks, Schegloff and Jefferson, is basically a
“rigorously empirical approach which avoids premature theory
construction. The methods are essentially inductive; search is made for
recurring patterns across many records of naturally occurring
conversations” (Levinson, 1983: 287). The data is based on real people
in real life conversing with each other and how language is used to get
their intention and message across. Unlike Discourse Analysis, CA does
not restrict data to categorisation. Instead, CA focuses on the
systematic properties of the sequential organization of conversation, in
the way in which utterances are designed to manage it (Jamaliah Mohd
Ali, 2004).
Although talk may appear as irregular, it is highly
systematic. Thus, the aim of CA is to examine the rules that underlie
conversations and towards which the participants accommodate. So, other
than analysing the general rules and structure of talk, CA also analyse
the regularities in more specific kinds of talks (
Discourse Analysis, 2003).
DATA AND METHODS
This
study examines logs of Yahoo! Chat interactions taken from a single
computer. The raw data consists of two logs of Yahoo! Chat interactions
in two public channels, which are
Professors’ Chat (Room 1) and
Study Group
(Room 4), with each log running approximately half an hour. Although
the channels are geared towards certain groups of people, these rooms
are accessible by anyone with a Yahoo! ID. At the time of logging, both
channels supported substantial levels of interaction. There were no
fixed agendas or topics being discussed; participants generally talk
about something that someone brought up. The logs also witness
interactions being carried out in English, although this is not a
requirement under Yahoo! Chat. This is could be because the chat rooms
are not regional, which perhaps would see the participants use the
regional language. While voice and video communication is turned on,
they were not utilized by the participants.
The objective of the
study is to look at the linguistic characteristics that the participants
or chatters display, which includes typography, spelling, and the
emoticons, how and why they are used as they occurred in public channel
interactions. The study will also look at turn-taking found in the chat
logs and how conversation and interaction take place with the merging of
spoken and written language in one medium. Since the interactions in
the chat rooms consist of the combination of human and computer-produced
utterance and transmission, the study will also take into consideration
how the mediation (the computer and Internet) affects the interaction.
FINDINGS
1. Linguistic Characteristics of Yahoo! Chat
Computer-mediated
communication has created new opportunities for real-time interaction
among geographically dispersed individuals sitting at their computer
keyboards. People engage in written conversation in the new linguistic
genre, which combines characteristics of both written and oral language
(Bechar-Israeli, 1996). The real-time, synchronous transmission of
utterances between participants gives a very face-to-face conversational
feel (
Reid, 1991). They type their messages, and the text of these messages appears on the screens of their interlocutors.
Because
language does not look as it does anymore in CMC due to the new
linguistic genre, it becomes less transparent. As a result, it heightens
meta-linguistic awareness. They are conscious of their audience and pay
special attention to the display of communicative competence, to how
their messages are displayed (Bauman, 1975, 1977 cited in
Danet, Ruedenberg-Wright and
Rosenbaum-Tamari,
1998). This is to ensure that they achieve the purpose of
communication, that is to be heard and understood by other
interlocutors.
Generally, since the messages are typed at a
keyboard, there is a tendency to use conventions of written English,
particularly spelling. However, a number of distinctive practices of
spelling are found in the channels. This can be seen in Example 1:
Example 1 : Spelling
Sample 1.1. : “Professors' Chat:1”
| Interaction | Substitution for : |
| 2. | old_lamp_lighter: isn't that a co | co – coincidence |
| 5. | platothedick: i hang out in perv rooms about 22 hours a day, the other two i'm in parent chat | perv – pervert |
| 82. | fisk_au: happy b'day | b’day – birthday |
| 105. | fisk_au: 1 no | no - know |
| 145. | CookedSoose: rather defanged him, then, didn it | didn – didn’t |
| 176. | fisk_au: rectum? damn near kilt em | em – them |
Sample 1.2. : “Study Group:4”
| Interaction | Substitution for : |
| 9. | mush_bear15: thats why men sucks | thats – that’s |
| 18. | mush_bear15: man dont care bout the feelings of a girl | dont – don’t
bout – about |
| 32. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: we're juz fine | juz – just |
| 46. | mush_bear15: not 4 a woman | 4 – for |
| 50. | priyanka_mishra_lko: what r u doing | r – are
u – you |
| 52. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: i think that's silly, if u would die for someone u loved, coz, why dont u find another one? | coz – because
dont – don’t
u – you |
| 60. | mush_bear15: ryt | ryt – right |
| 63. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: i'm telling the truth man, i mean if u wanna keep survive, why dont u think like that? | wanna – want to |
| 75. | mush_bear15: yup | yup – yes |
| 76. | mush_bear15: its ok to have a debate | its – it’s |
| 78. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: yea, its fun! | yea - yes |
| 87. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: so, mush bear, how r ya? | r - are
ya - you |
| 110. | mush_bear15: nope | nope - no |
| 118. | sonu_477: ya | ya - yes |
| 143. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: well, i think every problems will have the solutions and all we have to do is, juz face it, coz soon or later it will end | juz – just
coz – because |
| 146. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: well i have ever sad, but that wont stop me | wont – won’t |
| 168. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: i c | c - see |
| 180. | loudpraying: CAN U FURTHER UR EXPLAINATION? | ur – your |
| 185. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: so wat do u think? | wat - what |
| 193. | mush_bear15: UR ABSOLUTELY RYT | ur – you’re
ryt – right |
The
practices in Example 1 show that are several instances where the
spellings diverge from standard written English. The most common in the
study are substituting “you” with “u” or “ya” and “are” with “r”. There
are also instances of simplification of words, such as “b’day” for
“birthday”, “perv” for “pervert”, “ur” for “you are” and “ryt” for
“right”.
Other than some different ways of spelling, other
distinctive practices found in the chat logs are short-hand form of
communication, the dropping of apostrophe and hyphen, the dropping of
initial capital letters for proper nouns and beginning of sentence, and
lowercase for “I”. This can be observed in Example 2 below:
Example 2 : Short-hand Forms
Sample 2.1. : “Professors’ Chat:1”
| Interaction | Subtitution for : |
| CookedSoose: LOL it's too early to spell!!! | LOL – laughing out loud |
| 63. | old_lamp_lighter: g m selena | g m – good morning |
| 213. | selena_serene: omg | omg – oh, my God |
Sample 2.2. : “Study Group:4”
| Interaction | Subtitution for : |
| 223. | loudpraying: LOL | LOL – laughing out loud |
| 163. | mush_bear15: any1 | any1 - anyone |
The
chat participants also use short-hand form of communication as in
example 2 above, substituting “laughing out loud” (to indicate the
person is laughing) for “LOL” being the most common. Other short-hand
forms are “g m” for “good morning”, “omg” for “oh, my God” and “any1”
for “anyone”.
All these spellings would be considered
“vernacularizing” changes, and we would expect to find them used
especially among users of a particular channel (Paolillo, 1999). These
linguistic features somehow is similar with the sounds of spoken
English, such as “ya”, “yea” or “yup” for “yes” and “coz” for “because”.
This is one way the chat participants use to create the face-to-face
conversational feel in the medium. The dropping of apostrophe or hyphen,
the dropping of initial capital letters for proper nouns and beginning
of sentence, and small case for “I” as noted earlier could also be due
to the fact that these written English characteristics would be
invisible in spoken communication.
There are a few reasons why the
chat participants are using unconventional spelling and short-hand for
in the chat rooms. Because the interaction is carried out in the medium
and messages are sent out using the keyboard, participants typed as fast
as they can as so not to lose their turn in the interaction. Due to the
fact that messages on the screen scrolls up when new messages come in
(including messages generated automatically by Yahoo! Chat) ,
participants want to stay in the frame and not to be too far behind in
their responses, as that may make them to lose the floor.
It was
also observed that in the Professors’ Chat, the participants utilized
the conventional conversation transcription method, where uppercase is
used to indicate raising of voice on the word or sentence, either to
stress a point, shout or yell. Otherwise, all of the chat participants
use lowercase consistently. For example:
Example 3 : Uppercase (“Professors’ Chat:1”)
| Interaction | Purpose : |
| 6. | CookedSoose: so it's YOUR fault plato! | To blame only platothedick for bringing all the perverts into the chat room. |
| 68. | blue_eyed_jagged_edged: I am REALLY glad you gave me that image plato | Being sarcastic to platothedick, with the stress on the word “really”. |
| 96. | CookedSoose: HAPPY BIRTHDAY DEAR PLAAAAAAAAAAAATOOOOOOOOOOOO | To indicate shouting of “Happy Birthday” in an excited manner to platothedick.
The multiple “A” and “O” are to show loudness of the shout. |
| 137. | CookedSoose: morning PROP!!!!!!!!!!!! | To indicate excitement to see prop by shouting his name. |
| 152. | blue_eyed_jagged_edged: look at this...just fucking LOOK at it... | To indicate irritation, calling attention to the following statement. |
| 163. | blue_eyed_jagged_edged: I mean for fuck's SAKE | To indicate irritation, with stress on the word “sake” |
| 169. | selena_serene: it's ALIVE | To stress the word “alive”, as if surprise, in a jocular manner. |
| 117. | blue_eyed_jagged_edged: look at THIS | To indicate irritation, calling attention to the subsequent statement. |
| 200. | selena_serene: YESSSSSSS | To indicate excitement in agreeing to a suggestion. |
| 208. | selena_serene: GLORIA,..G L O R I A ......gloria......... | To indicate singing and shouting the name “Gloria”. |
In
Example 3 above, we can see that the chat participants use uppercase is
used to indicate raising of voice on a particular word or sentence,
whether it is to stress a point, shout or yell. This is perhaps done
with specific intention in mind, such as blaming (line 6), being
sarcastic (line 68), showing excitement (lines 96, 137, 200), showing
irritation (lines 152, 163) and showing loudness (lines 169, 208). This
shows that the chat participants are aware of the conventional
conversation transcription method and know how to use and manipulate it
as paralinguistic markers in chat rooms to compensate the lack of visual
and auditory clues to communicate with others.
2. Emoticons
Emoticons
in CMC are facial expressions made by a certain combinations of
keystrokes, usually producing an image of a face sideways. They are
icons for the expression of emotion, often indicating non-seriousness or
playfulness, and are considered as an aspect of paralinguistics.
Generally emoticons are used in online chats, E-mails, or online message
boards (
Danet, Ruedenberg-Wright and
Rosenbaum-Tamari, 1998).
In
this study, it was found that chat participants did not make use of
emoticons a lot. Most of the time, they played with words to express
their intention and emotions, especially chat participants in the
Professors’ Chat:1. However, chat participants in Study Group:4 used it
quite frequently, most of the time to show their emotions in reference
to statements or questions. The following are examples of emoticons and
the purpose of their use in the study (emoticons which are not part of
the conversations are excluded from this analysis).
Example 4 : Emoticons
Sample 4.1. : “Professors’ Chat:1”
| Interaction | Purpose |
| 15. | just4nz: every chatroom needs its own resident pariah - Let Plato be the delegated one :D | The emoticon is a grinning face used to indicate that he is joking. |
| 140. | propagumbhis: Gilly *L* | The emoticon is a type of smiley used to greet CookedSoose and indicate that he is pleased to see her there. |
Sample 4.2. : “Study Group:4”
| Interaction | Purpose |
| 68. | loudpraying: :-B | The
emoticon is a face with two teeth showing (implying a typical nerd),
used to indicate that he has nothing more to say and his argument ends
there. |
| 89. | loudpraying: ;-) | The emoticon is a winking face, to indicate that he is joking. |
| 136. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: i almost never! :D | To indicate that she is joking. |
| 192. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: :/ | The emoticon is a confused face, to show that she is confused. |
| 207. | mush_bear15: :D | To indicate that she is laughing to sweetsunshinebrightenyou’s joke about someone they both know. |
| 222. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: :) | To show that she is in agreement to loudpraying’s funny statement. |
| 226. | mush_bear15: >:) | The
emoticon is known as “evil smile”, here it is used to indicate that she
agrees to loudpraying’s ridicule on someone they both know. |
| 229. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: i'm 17 f, and call me Dee :) | To show that she is introducing herself in a friendly manner. |
| 233. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: :) | To show that she is pleased to meet others in the chat room. |
| 244. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: nice meeting u :) | Smiling to mush_bear15, to show that she is pleased to meet mush_bear15. |
From
example 4 above, we can see that chat participants use emoticons to
compensate the lack of visual and auditory clues in the interaction on
the Internet. The use of emoticons is seen as a display of awareness on
the part of the chat participants of the importance of visual and
auditory clues in interaction. To replace emoticons with words would
take more time to type them, so the use of emoticons can also be seen as
a short cut to get messages across.
3. Turn-taking
Turn-taking
in spoken conversation can be said to follow a normative ideal of
precisely alternating turns, it refers to the timing of the transition
from one speaker turn to the next, which is ideally supposed to occur
with no (or minimal) gap, and no overlap between speakers. It is
alternating because it is expected that participants will take turns
speaking in an orderly fashion. Thus, in dyadic exchanges, one person
speaks, the other responds; the first speaks again, the second takes the
following turn, and so forth. CMC, in contrast, exhibits numerous
violations of both the “no gap, no overlap” principle and the principle
of orderly turn alternation (Herring, 1999). Researches on
conversational interaction shows simultaneous feedback has an important
role as it signals listenership, timing turn-taking and maintaining
continuous interaction (Mclaughlin, 1984).
Interaction on the
Internet in the study has shown successful turn-taking taking place,
where there is no overlap and minimal gap between the exchanges and one
speaker speaks at one time. For example:
Example 5 : No overlap and no gap
| 6. | platothedick: i hang out in perv rooms about 22 hours a day, the other two i'm in parent chat |
| 7. | CookedSoose: so it's YOUR fault plato! |
| 8. | platothedick: what is my fault? |
| 9. | CookedSoose: you bring all the pervs back here with you |
| 10. | platothedick: it probably is |
| 11. | CookedSoose: lol |
In
the example above, we can see the exchanges between platothedick and
CookedSoose are not interrupted and there is no overlap or gap. Both of
them take the floor in the instance they see the message from the other
appears on their screen.
There are also instances where the
chatter (speaker) selected which chat participant to speak next by
producing the first part of the adjacency pair, such as in a greeting or
a question, although they are not always successful because of the
multi-participant nature of the chat room. Some examples of adjacency
pairs (greetings) are as follows:
Example 6 : Adjacency pairs (Greetings)
Sample 6.1
| 61. | nflfirefighter: Morning Selena |
| 65. | selena_serene: hello nfl |
Sample 6.2
| 71. | CookedSoose: hello selena |
| 73. | selena_serene: soosey |
However,
although turn-taking in Internet chat is similar to spoken
communication, researchers in CMC have found that there are various
limitations imposed on group interaction by the properties of the
medium, such as high production and reception, and “chaos”. One of the
properties of the medium which are obstacles to interaction is the lack
of simultaneous feedback which is due to the features of CMC. Online
chat is text-based, and chat participants rely on fewer channels than
face-to-face interaction for transmission of the message. Because users
do not see other participants, they do not have access to paralinguistic
and non-verbal information, which are equally important as the verbal
information. Another feature is the fact that most free chat systems
make use of messages are sent in their entirety when the message
originator presses “send” or “return”, rather than one keystroke at a
time. Therefore, participants cannot respond while message is being
typed, and they do not even know that are being addressed to until a
complete message appears on the screen (Herring, 1999). As a result,
discontinuity and overlap within turn sequence occur.
Another
problem is disrupted turn adjacency, which is due to CMC systems
transmitting messages linearly, in the order received by the system.
Thus in multi-participant interactions, a message may be separated in
linear order from a previous message it is responding to, if other
messages are been sent in the meantime (Herring, 1999). We can see this
in Example 7 below (messages generated automatically by Yahoo! Chat
system are excluded from this analysis):
Example 7a : Overlapping and interleaved interaction in Professors’ Chat:1
| 71. | CookedSoose: hello selena |
| 73. | selena_serene: soosey |
| 74. | fisk_au: selena |
| 75. | just4nz: Good morning Selena |
| 76. | selena_serene: fisky |
| 77. | platothedick: selena |
| 78. | blue_eyed_jagged_edged: hi slee |
| 79. | selena_serene: pluto |
| 80. | platothedick: i'm old today |
| 81. | platothedick: i feel ancient |
| 82. | selena_serene: is it your Birthday? |
| 83. | fisk_au: happy b'day |
| 84. | blue_eyed_jagged_edged: slee you lost your pretty font again |
| 85. | selena_serene: heh heh |
| 86. | platothedick: i think i have a complex |
| 87. | CookedSoose: it's your birthday plato???? |
| 88. | CookedSoose: happy birthday dear plato |
| 89. | fisk_au: I like this colour |
| 90. | platothedick: funny enough gilly it is |
| 91. | CookedSoose: happy birthday dear plato! |
| 92. | fisk_au: should I change? |
| 93. | platothedick: thanks |
| 94. | selena_serene: fisk,..no,..it looks like cat vomit |
| 95. | platothedick: fisk no one reads it anyway |
| 96. | blue_eyed_jagged_edged: yes fisk change |
In
the sample above, because of the number of participants the chat room
in the study is high, exchanges are overlapped and interleaved. Here, we
can see that the participants respond upwards to a previous participant
in each case. One interaction is between platothedick and
selena_serene, fisk_au and CookedSoose, and another is between
blue_eyed_jagged_edged and selena_serene. We can see that selena_serene
was engaged for a moment with two interactions at the same time with
platothedick and blue_eyed_jagged_edged (lines 82 – 85). Later (line
88), fisk_au initiated another conversation with the rest of the
participants, which they responded to. Example 7a shows that exchanges
overlap and turns are often disrupted by other messages in between.
These patterns of interaction can be represented (based on Herring,
1999) in Example 7b:
Example 7b : Overlapping and interleaved interaction in Professors’ Chat:1
In online chat, overlap, disrupted adjacency and interleaved exchange
are very common. The lack of simultaneous feedback, time taken to type a
message and multiple conversations and interactions in one chat room
cause speaking turns to be lines away from one another. As a result
turn-taking appears to be chaotic and incoherent.
However,
although online interaction lacks certain important features of spoken
communication, this study observed that chat participants were able to
adapt to the medium in order to make the interaction successful (based
on Herring, 1999). In turn-taking, they have created methods of
signaling listenership and holding the floor, despite the nature of the
medium and CMC.
In signaling listenership, some of the chat
participants use emoticons, short-hand forms of communication (such as
LOL), “heh heh” and “oh”. It is important because “practices such as
these heighten the interactivity of CMC by signaling listenership and
encouraging others to continue” (Herring, 1999). We can see this in
Example 8 below:
Example 8 : Signaling listenership
Sample 8.1 : Study Group:4
| 220. | mush_bear15: HE DONT KNOW HOW TO CHAT |
| 221. | mush_bear15: THATS ALL |
| 222. | sweetsunshinebrightenyou: :) |
Sample 8.2 : Professors’ Chat:1
| 9. | CookedSoose: you bring all the pervs back here with you |
| 10. | platothedick: it probably is |
| 11. | CookedSoose: lol |
Sample 8.3 : Professors’ Chat:1
| 84. | blue_eyed_jagged_edged: slee you lost your pretty font again |
| 85. | selena_serene: heh heh |
Sample 8.4 : Professors’ Chat:1
| 167. | fisk_au: it twitched |
| 169. | wickedly_innocent1: ohhhhh |
The
chat participants in the study were also found to be able to indicate
to others that they are still holding the floor, specifically to those
whom they are talking to, although messages from other chatters
sometimes interleaved. They are able to do this quite successfully
because those in the conversation were found not interrupting the
message flow. Basically, the chat participants use two methods of
holding the floor, which are sending incomplete sentences until they are
finished talking (as in Example 9) and using multiple full-stops (as in
Example 10).
Example 9 : Holding the floor (incomplete sentences)
Sample 9.1 : Professors’ Chat:1
| 23. | platothedick: i've frozen or something |
| 24. | platothedick: but |
| 26. | platothedick: my penis still tingles |
Sample 9.2 : Professors’ Chat:1
| 156. | fisk_au: looks |
| 158. | fisk_au: at |
| 159. | fisk_au: 'it' |
Sample 9.3 : Study Group:4
| 7. | mush_bear15: depression |
| 10. | mush_bear15: gives teenagers |
| 11. | mush_bear15: stress |
Sample 9.4 : Study Group:4
| 58. | mush_bear15: nope |
| 59. | mush_bear15: she's |
| 60. | mush_bear15: ryt |
Example 10 : Holding the floor (multiple full-stops)
Sample 10.1 : Professors’ Chat:1
| 153. | blue_eyed_jagged_edged: look at this...just fucking LOOK at it... |
| 160. | blue_eyed_jagged_edged: 'How are we to decide whether the man or woman we send to parliament is earning their keep?' |
Sample 10.2 : Professors’ Chat:1
| 221. | fisk_au: I went to school with a kid clled Grammar |
| 222. | fisk_au: oh |
| 224. | fisk_au: wait... |
| 226. | fisk_au: it was Grahame |
As
we can see, although online chat lacks features of face-to-face
interaction, chat participants in the study were found to be able to
compensate that lacking with their creativity to ensure communication in
online chat is successful.
CONCLUSION
To
conclude, interaction on chat systems on the Internet has produced a new
set of systems called the Internet language. This new system of
communication differs from the conventional type of communication
because it is a result of convergence of both written and spoken
language in one medium. Despite the weaknesses due to the nature of the
medium, communication in online chat can be considered as successful in
getting the message across, similar to spoken communication.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bechar-Israeli, H. (1996). FROM TO : Nicknames, play, and identity on internet relay chat.
Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 1, 2. Retrieved 19
th January 2004 from http://www/ascusc.org/jmcm/vol1/issue2/bechar
Bruckman, A. (2003). Chat (Online).
Microsoft Encarta Encyclopedia Deluxe 2004. Microsoft Corporation.
Byrne, E. (1994).
The Formation of Relationships on Internet Relay Chat (IRC). A
thesis submitted to the University of Western Sydney, Nepean as partial
fulfilment for the degree of Bachelor of Arts (Honours) in Applied
Communication Studies.
http://www.irchelp.org/irchelp/communication-research/academic/byrne-e-cyberfusion-1993/thesis1.html
Comer, D.E. (2003). The Internet.
Microsoft Encarta Encyclopedia Deluxe 2004.Microsoft Corporation.
Computer User High-Tech Dictionary (2004). Retrieved 26
th January 2004 from http://www.computeruser.com/resources/dictionary.html
Danet, B., Ruedenberg-Wright, L. and Rosenbaum-Tamari, Y. (1998). Hmmm...Where's That Smoke Coming From?
Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 2, 4. Retrieved 19
th January 2004 from http://www.ascusc.org/jcmc/vol2/issue4/danet.html
Discourse Analysis (Textlinguistics, Pragmatics, Conversational Analysis, Critical Discourse Analysis). (2003). Retrieved 01st March 2004 from http://emile.uni-graz.at/pub/02w/2003-03-0100.PDF
Herring, S. (1999). Interactional Coherence in CMC.
Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 4, 4. Retrieved 19th January 2004 from http://www.ascusc.org/jcmc/vol4/issue4/herring.html
Jamaliah Mohd Ali. (2004).
Pragmatics: Conversational Analysis. Language and Linguistics Faculty, UM.
Levinson, S.C. (1983).
Pragmatics. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press
McLaughlin M. L. (1984).
Conversation: How Talk Is Organized.Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.
Paolillo, J. (1999). The Virtual Speech Community: Social Network and Language
Variation on IRC.
Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 4, 4. Retrieved 19
th January 2004 from http://www.ascusc.org/jcmc/vol4/issue4/paolillo.html
Reid, E. (1991).
Electropolis: Communication and community on Internet Relay Chat.
Unpublished electronic paper adapted from a B.A. Honors thesis, Dept.
of History, University of Melbourne, Australia. Retrieved 19
th January 2004 from http://irchelp.org/irchelp/communication-research/academic/academic-reid-e-electropolis-1991.html